Cookie Shop · Dolcliffe Common, Mexborough
The Cookie Smith Menu & Prices
Here is what you can typically expect on the counter at The Cookie Smith: 30 items across 5 sections, from classic cookies to free-from cookies & drinks.
Indicative menu. Items and prices are typical for this style of bakery and are not supplied by The Cookie Smith. Always ask staff about allergens.
Classic Cookies
- Peanut butter cookieVN £3.25 Crumbly, salty-sweet peanut butter cookie with a criss-cross top.
- Double chocolate fudge cookieV £3.15 Dark, fudgy cookie with molten chocolate pockets throughout.
- Smarties cookieV £2.40 Vanilla cookie studded with colourful chocolate beans, a firm favourite with kids.
- Milk chocolate chip cookiePopularV £2.65 Chewy brown butter cookie loaded with milk chocolate chunks.
- White chocolate and macadamia cookieVN £3.65 Buttery cookie with creamy white chocolate and roasted macadamia nuts.
- Triple chocolate cookiePopularV £2.60 Cocoa dough packed with dark, milk and white chocolate pieces.
- Oatmeal and raisin cookieV £2.60 Soft-baked oat cookie with plump raisins and a hint of cinnamon.
Stuffed & Loaded Cookies
- Cookies and cream cookieV £4.50 Chocolate dough mixed with Oreo pieces and white chocolate chunks.
- Red velvet cream cheese cookieV £4.45 Crimson cocoa cookie hiding a sweet cream cheese centre.
- Biscoff stuffed cookiePopularV £4.60 Brown sugar cookie filled with Biscoff spread and topped with a biscuit.
- Pistachio Dubai chocolate cookieVN £5.25 Cookie filled with pistachio cream and crunchy kataifi, topped with chocolate.
- Lemon blueberry cookieV £3.90 Zesty lemon cookie with juicy blueberries and a lemon glaze.
- Nutella stuffed cookiePopularVN £3.80 Thick New York-style cookie with a gooey Nutella core.
- Salted caramel pretzel cookieV £4.00 Chewy cookie with caramel chunks, crushed pretzels and sea salt.
Boxes & Gifts
- Mini cookie tubV £7.30 A tub of bite-sized cookies in mixed flavours for grazing.
- Cookie dough tub (frozen)V £10.50 Ready-to-bake cookie dough balls for warm cookies at home.
- Cookie letterbox giftV £15.00 Six cookies packed to fit through the letterbox with a personal note.
- Box of 8 cookiesV £22.00 Eight cookies of your choice, perfect for sharing.
- Giant cookie cake 10"PopularV £22.50 Huge cookie decorated with buttercream and your personalised message.
Cookie Desserts
- Cookie dough potPopularVEF £5.40 Edible, egg-free cookie dough with chocolate chips, eaten with a spoon.
- Skillet cookieV £7.45 Molten cookie baked in a mini skillet, served warm with ice cream.
- Cookie milkshakeV £6.50 Thick milkshake blended with a whole cookie and topped with cream.
- Warm cookie sundaePopularV £6.05 Fresh-baked cookie with vanilla ice cream, sauce and sprinkles.
- Brownie cookieV £3.25 Crinkle-topped brownie batter cookie with a glossy, fudgy middle.
Free-From Cookies & Drinks
- Vegan chocolate chip cookiePopularVVGDFEF £3.70 Plant-based cookie with dark chocolate chunks and a chewy centre.
- Vegan oat and ginger cookieVVGDFEF £2.65 Dairy-free oat cookie with chewy stem ginger pieces.
- Hot chocolateVGF £3.85 Velvety hot chocolate made with whole milk and cocoa.
- Cold milkVGF £2.20 Ice-cold glass of whole or oat milk, the classic cookie companion.
- Gluten-free peanut butter cookieVGFN £3.50 Flourless peanut butter cookie with a soft, crumbly bite.
- Gluten-free double chocolate cookiePopularVGF £3.95 Rich cocoa cookie made with a gluten-free flour blend.
Ordering tips for The Cookie Smith
- Arrive early for the widest choice – bread and the most popular bakes often sell out by lunchtime.
- Allergen information must be available on request under UK law – ask before you buy if you have an allergy.
Make a morning of it
All in MexboroughOther bakeries near The Cookie Smith
